Authorities utility regulators licensed a plan to advertise electrical automobiles in Kansas, however didn’t give Evergy pre-approval for increasing its charging station community at a value to ratepayers.
The Kansas Company Fee unanimously backed an order issued Monday, which got here on the heels of a non-unanimous settlement settlement.
Evergy’s transportation electrification portfolio is highlighted by a collection of charging station rebate packages, but additionally consists of charging service charges, client training, administration budgeting and monitoring of program prices.
A associated growth of Evergy’s Clear Cost Community was praised by regulators, however didn’t obtain the extent of fee help the corporate had requested for.
“Evergy’s proposal was designed to encourage funding within the infrastructure wanted to help broader adoption of electrical automobiles,” firm spokesperson Gina Penzig mentioned in an electronic mail. “Electrical transportation with price buildings that encourage off-peak charging has the potential to make the electrical grid extra environment friendly by growing use throughout occasions of decrease demand. This helps drive down prices for all prospects.”
The corporate estimates $72.three million in buyer advantages to the Kansas metro territory and $46.9 million to the central Kansas space by means of 2040, in accordance with paperwork filed with KCC.
“Lengthy-term, electrical car charging has the potential to cut back prices for all prospects by spreading the utility’s fastened prices amongst extra customers,” fee workers mentioned in a information launch. “Evergy can be permitted to submit the prices for rebates, buyer training, and administration of this system for Fee evaluation in its subsequent price case.”
Rebates and charger community
The rebates embrace tons of of {dollars} in incentives for householders to put in Degree 2 charging, which use 240-volt shops to cost automobiles quicker than conventional 120-volt shops.
Builders could be in line for different rebates supposed to get such chargers put in in newly-constructed properties, whereas third events might get rebates for business charging infrastructure. Giant fleet operators, equivalent to business automobiles and metropolis buses, might get decrease charges for off-peak charging.
Evergy will get a funds of $10 million for its business charger rebate program.
Evergy owns and operates the shareholder-funded Clear Cost Community, boasting greater than 900 electrical car charging stations. Evergy claims it makes the Kansas Metropolis space the nation’s “electrical car infrastructure chief.”
Evergy’s proposed $13.5 million growth would have goal underserved areas, greater than quadrupling the variety of charging stations within the utility’s central Kansas area.
The corporate had requested the fee to search out the CCN growth is “prudent from a decisional perspective.” The fee denied the request.
“Evergy requested preapproval to develop the community and search restoration of these investments from ratepayers in future price circumstances,” KCC workers mentioned. “The Fee denied the request for preapproval as untimely.”
Workers famous the federal infrastructure act has cash earmarked for electrical car charging stations. Kansas might see $40 million over 5 years, plus the chance to use for the $2.5 billion pool of grant funding for EV charging.
It’s unclear whether or not the funding will occur with out KCC’s approval. Penzig, the Evergy spokesperson, mentioned the corporate remains to be evaluation that portion of the fee’s order.
Commissioners mentioned that Evergy might proceed with its plan and attempt to restoration prices in future price circumstances, however it will bear its conventional burden of displaying these prices had been prudent.
Their order signifies that Evergy would want to indicate that an growth focused an underserved space, the corporate sought different funding alternatives and it gave federal funds a chance to serve buyer wants earlier than constructing its personal infrastructure.
Extra:President Joe Biden’s signature infrastructure package is now law. What does it mean for Kansas?
Proactive response and ‘massive advantages’
“I do need to give Evergy an enormous thanks and acknowledge them for a way proactive they’ve been on learning and supporting this potential transition to electrical automobiles,” KCC Chair Andrew French mentioned. “If we do handle this proper, there are massive advantages to come back to all prospects.”
Whereas Evergy argued the plan would profit all shoppers and was a proactive response to main automakers transferring towards electrical automobiles, the corporate confronted opposition.
The settlement settlement was negotiated by KCC workers, Evergy and the Residents Utility Ratepayer Board. The Pure Sources Protection Council, American Gas & Petrochemical Producers and ChargePoint participated in discussions however opposed the settlement.
The gas group argued the plan “will unfairly profit Evergy on the expense of gasoline and diesel gas producers” and that EV chargers are an “optionally available luxurious,” not an “important utility service,” in accordance with the order. They argued that Evergy was attempting to stimulate demand, fairly than assembly present buyer wants.
Whereas electrical car use might assist cut back greenhouse gasoline emissions from oil combustion engines, some questioned whether or not a public utility must be stimulating demand for the electrical energy it sells.
“It permits people within the Evergy territory to think about the acquisition of an EV car, as I am positive costs will come down and availability will go up, to additional understand a rebate after they make that buy,” Commissioner Susan Duffy mentioned.
The buyer group was usually supportive of selling cleaner power, however was not satisfied the corporate had demonstrated a buyer want for its charging community and growth could be anti-competitive.
“We additionally consider the utility shouldn’t be figuring out public insurance policies,” a consultant mentioned throughout a earlier evidentiary listening to. “This must be left as much as our duly-elected representatives of this state.”
KCC workers sought to “shield a burgeoning aggressive market from Evergy’s monopoly energy.”
Commissioner Dwight Eager mentioned the order is meant to supply for a extra aggressive market.
“Competitors amongst suppliers normally results in higher service at decrease or aggressive costs, and it supplies extra selections as properly for shoppers,” he mentioned.
Jason Tidd is a statehouse reporter for the Topeka Capital-Journal. He will be reached by electronic mail at jtidd@gannett.com. Observe him on Twitter @Jason_Tidd.
